I asked for it. I got it. Some good, healthy, swift kicks regarding yesterdays 2 part frothy rants on This Ain’t No Blogging (parts 1 and 2), both via comments and trackbacks.

Thanks Scott, Dan. Stephen, James, David, Rino (I think, I cannot read Norwegian), Brian, Tom and everyone else who decides to pile on.

More or less what I was hoping for by lobbing some silly big rocks into the blog pond. Rightfully so, pointed out that

  • blogs are blogs without comments
  • comments are a curse (spam, overload, marginal value) and a blessing
  • blogs can work well as pure publishing, or info sharing
  • blogs can be news scoops or personal rants
  • and much more…

Yup, I asked for a whupping, and got one.

I was trying to make a subtler point, that likely missed the mark. Not the first or last time. No one can really singularly define or categorize something as broad, diverse, sprawling, evolving, morphing as weblogs.

Scott Leslie remarked about how he gets lots of comments asking for this “simple defintion” of a weblog. We all have our personal theory based on our immediate experiences (I blogged perhaps what my own is, but why would I expect it to to mesh for everyone out there?), but there are quite a few more out there that are just as valid.

So it is all blogging. Or none of it is. There is no universal law on the subject.

it is kind of funny because my thoughts about comments started when I had read something at Tom’s Tuttle’s SVC blog, and wanted to send him some thoughts. Lacking comments or an email, I just wrote my own blog entry about it. Somehow, in a day or two, he caught it, perhaps via RSS or a referral, and I got a nice email note from him. The connections can work in a multitude of ways (see the small pieces philosophy) not just one.

Thanks for joining in the fray, as I tried stirring up the Abbey soup. And yes, I really ought to turn this thing off and get some work done.

The post "Kick the Dog About the Blog" was originally cracked open and scrambled from a rotten egg at CogDogBlog (http://cogdogblog.com/2004/08/kick-the/) on August 4, 2004.


  • Rino Zandee

    Hi Alan,

    Actually it’s Dutch, not Norwegian ;-)

    I used your post and Tom’s comments to say something [i.e. echo-blogging with context] to my fellow Dutch Edu-bloggers [a small bunch], who, by the way, all have CDB on their blogroll.

    Thanks for all your inspiring stuff [blogs as well as scripts] !

  • Alan Levine


    Ouch for my language error! Another pitfall of blogs- writing fast and not checking the facts. Thanks for making the connection, I see a number of the Dutch blogs in my Trackback so I have been curious.

    regards from Arizona

  • Kick the Dog About the Blog

    Alan writes at “cogdogblog” (excerpted): I was trying to make a subtler point, that likely missed the mark.