I recently got set up with a wireless broadband card for access to the net via my mobile provider (it is Alltel, but the network is Sprint). While up in the mountains of Strawberry, Arizona, it was time for an old fashioned western shootout between my satellite internet connection (Hughes) and the new mobile card.

Dish vs the card

Despite a lot of connectivity issues the first year with Hughes, I must admit that in the last 12 or 18 months, it was worked very reliably. The satellite modem is connected to an Apple Airport wireless running 802.11(b) speeds, so capable of sending up to 2 MB/s, much more than the theoretical maximum of the dish (1 MB/s).

So as the arbitrator, I turned to Speakeasy Speed Test… I love the little speedometer graphics.

The Dish was first, and pulled in an impressive 998 kbps download and surprisingly, the upload speed was 568 kbps- surprisingly because I thought the limit of my plan was 256 up (shhhhh, dont tell them!)

Hughes network speed test

Next up was the little guy, the Franklin CDU-550 USB network doo-hickey. Now, this is not much of a contest, since we are out of range of the digital network, so the maximum it ought to do is about 128 kbps, if it gets a signal at all. We plug it in, give a few moments to find a network… 1 bar, woah, it got 3 bars! And the results showed 128 kbps download and 81 kbps up:

Alltel speed test results

So yes, the Dish wins the big medal, but I am pleased that in a pinch up here, I can still get connected. I have a backup! And for a bit of perspective, the speed of the mobile network is 5 times what we had pre-Dish (dialup). And, for some looking forward, some suggest the internet may in a few years get so clogged, we will all be back to pokey speeds in the net.

So winners all the way around.

The post "Mobile Vs Dish Speed" was originally pulled from under moldy cheese at the back of the fridge at CogDogBlog (http://cogdogblog.com/2007/11/speedtest/) on November 25, 2007.

No comments yet.

Leave a Comment

All fields are required. Your email address will not be published.