It was kind of like two blog posts unexpectedly colliding or passing in the night past a burning barge.
On Sunday, Bryan Alexander asked some large questions about How would you design a professional association for the future?. I also wrote about the impending death of Storify and in their dying process leaving no plan for preservation of the content users placed there.
The next day there was this twitter bomb
— Scott Robison (@OtterScotter) December 18, 2017
Public and private channels are running with shock and WTF. I had to laugh when I got emails and DMs asking if I know what was going on; I left NMC in 2011. I got bupkis (look Clark, I spelled it correctly).
Let me be totally clear. Although I left NMC in 2011 under less than ideal conditions, the reason was a yearn for an adventure afforded by an unexpected inheritance. I’ve hardly looked back only because I was looking ahead. None of what I’ve done since then would have been possible without the experience and connections I got in five years at NMC. Those years were a career accelerator and I am still riding on that momentum.
Advice is going out now to not be concocting stories and speculations about what is going on. That sounds nice but totally disregards the human nature to understand.
We humans are story powered creatures, and if not provided information about something important to us, we will naturally create our own tales. Try stopping human curiosity.
And whatever happened, it’s now being sorted out in very small circles, probably surrounded by lawyers. The way in which this was cryptically communicated, out of the blue, in the middle of the production of the Horizon Report, shortly before Christmas, signifies it is seismic or atomic bomb intensity.
NMC has a long history of many many many many people participating, contributing to a Consortium, a community, now which is left out in the cold muttering, “WTF?”
It will be told sometime. Oh well.
The thing that ties Bryan and my posts are in his follow-up story on what was happening at NMC (and I do have to say very few people blog at the instensity, frequency, thoroughness, longness, linkedfull-ness as Bryan):
There is also the question of NMC web content. The announcement’s language suggests the site will go away, at least in its current, accessible form. That’s a lot of material.
It’s more than the Horizon Reports, the web site is a huge legacy, and what if the legal outcome is shutting it down? I’ve got some expansions on my comment to Bryan’s post. Google removed the search parameter to see how many web pages link to NMC, but I’d say its in the 10s to 100s of thousands.
All of which potentially might end up in the giant pile of dead links. I cited one of the best examples I know of an organization, IT COnversations, that was winding down and thoughtfully managed their web history with an eye for the future.
The remaining assets of the Conversations Network (cash and intellectual property) will be acquired by the Internet Archive, another U.S. 501(c)(3) non-profit organization. All existing programs will be moved to the Internet Archive where the world will be able to continue to listen to them for free.
Trying to anticipate some of the questions you may have:
We hope to preserve all existing URLs by running a “redirection server” for many years if not permanently.
Moving all NMC content to the Internet Archive would be a worthy thing to happen (though likely not possible after this story weaves through the courtroom), it’s still problematic for all of these busted links. My hunch is less than a single digit of the internet knows after seeing a “site not found” message how to seek out the copy in the Wayback Machine.
A lot of history is there, and even lacking a concerted effort to preserve history, this is going to be the best avenue likely for finding NMC stuff http://web.archive.org/web/*/nmc.org
It’s valuable, but not perfect. Not an archive.
Archives are really really really important but most organizations, companies, and individuals don’t think about history or the idea that what they publish on the web is part of an interconnected fabric.
My big charge when joining NMC in 2006 was developing a new web site that would be dynamic and manage the membership and conference registration. The existing web site I nicknamed “Orange Squares” was 1990s vintage, static and using HTML tables for display:
As stuff was updated each year for the conference they just overwrite the previous year’s content. It took about a year, working with ideas from membership and getting a lot of contracted help, because, believe it or not, I chose drupal as the platform. Seriously. Because of the transaction stuff and the membership stuff.
How do I know this? Heck, I blogged it. But even at the time, I preserved the previous site at
archive.nmc.org (no longer active).
I did a lot more research at the time I was building sites, poking around the NMC file server, finding remnants of even earlier versions of the web site, and the very founding of the organization at some media meeting in Japan, and posting them online (sorry I am running out of energy to find them) (you won’t find them on the current site).
Keeping the legacy and providing as much of the work we did on the web was a driving force for me, always has been. The organization put a lot of effort in PDF versions of papers and reports, on my own I manually converted them to web content. You cannot link to page 7 of the PDF of the 2010 Horizon report. You cannot comment on it. It’s one single [pretty] content blob.
I tried to change that in my first WordPress Multisite project–
http://wp.nmc.org/, where I put several years of Horizon Reports and other papers online, in a linkable format, and where, using early versions of CommentPress, people could comment on publications at the paragraph level.
This too is totally gone, except for the Internet Archive’s versions.
There was the Second Life Observer
http://sl.nmc.org/ … now gone except for the Internet Archive
And later, when NMC got into the Second Life hosting and building, NMC Virtual Worlds
http://virtualworlds.nmc.org … now gone except for the Internet Archive
I arranged, recorded, produced, and published a podcast series called NMC Conversations
http://web.nmc.org/conversations/ … also gone except for the Internet Archive
There’s a lot of them I might be forgetting… oh yes, a critical one! This was my first experience “hacking” a WordPress theme to create a new site for an old project NMC managed… Pachyderm Services
http://pachyderm.nmc.org. I cannot even get to it in the Internet archive because of some funky redirect from nmc.org, but I have my own record
This post was rather pivotal for my career… shortly after I was at the 2008 Northern Voice Conference and offered this WordPress makeover as a presentation in the Unconference Day (I miss Moose Camp, that was all you Scott Leslie).
I did not know it but there was a guy named Matt in the audience who knows a bit about WordPress. Later that year he invited me to speak at a little conference he ran in San Francisco:
One of my better WordPress efforts at NMC, maybe the last, for some reason is still working MIDEA Marcus Institute for Digital Education in the Arts
http://midea.nmc.org/. Maybe the NMC WordPress reaper forgot this one; the most recent post was 2014:
I’m leaving out all of the Horizon and other project wikis I set up, these are working because they are hosted on WikiSpaces. No one kept up the indices, but they used it up to this year that’s all my design work there (actually I got a big lift on that from Jo Kay more known for her Virtual Worlds work who refused to accept payment or credit).
At it looks like NMC was still using the hand coded web-based voting tool I built myself
http://horizon.nmc.org/voting-tool/. Before I got to NMC the way the voting was done was by emailing a Word doc to Horizon Board members, who edited it, sent it back to the CEO, who than hand entered votes in a spreadsheet.
I knew there was a better way.
It provided each participant record of their votes, and at an admin level it summarized the status and summary voting. And it archived data year to year.
It might be the most useful thing I built. It’s all PHP and mySQL hand coded.
When I left NMC I saved a lot, but I did not export the WordPress site data, I saw no need for me to have it. I have a hard drive full of other flotsam and websum. I did make a mistake of putting a lot of video on blip.tv (which bit the dust a long time ago) but I do have most of the original video on that hard drive.
Last year I dug in and restored a necessary classic, the Second Life presentation where Jim Groom and Tom Woodward shooting flamethrowers at LMS zombies.
I imagine when some new IT person comes on an looks on the pile of **** I left, it’s easier to cut and build. Who wants to manage a bunch of old WordPress sites… except that it’s rather easy to convert WordPress sites to static HTML.
And it’s happened before. When I left the Maricopa Community Colleges in 2006 (to work for NMC), sometime later they took a flamethrower to every shred of web content I created between 1993 and 2006… There was a good cause as a lot of my mid 1990 vintage sites were based on perl scripts writing to openly editable text files, a security nightmare.
I’ve been reclaiming them myself at http://mcli.cogdogblog.com (but that’s a different blog post)
But rather than try to assess, close problems like that, the most typical IT solution is a total bulldozering of web content. Who gives a f*** about old web sites?
Well I do.
What we really need are like a million more librarians out there helping IT people appreciate the importance of careful archiving.
What we need are more people to gather, share, and care about organizing, curating, preserving our own stuff, and the stuff of organizations we work for. The orgs are likely not going to do this work; it’s up to the individual. Who is game?
This blog post was meant to be a bit shorter. Sort of. I could probably dig up more NMC paraphernalia all night long. But what for?
My bets are the nmc.org content, which is a fraction of its real history, will be bulldozed. At least we have shreds in the Internet Archive and the memories of some nostalgic people.
Update: Dec 21 2017
I may be a better archivist than I thought; I just opened my hard drive of NMC archive materials and found more than I expected.
First, I remembered the archive site I did of an earlier version of the NMC web site as
greensite.nmc.org no longer available (partly on the Internet Archive, images missing) … it’s all there.
Also there were all wordpress sites, a few more I forgot about. And… drumroll… I did do MySQL dumps for the wordpress sites, woo hoo!
In theory, someone could re-establish these WordPress sites, than do Site Sucking process to convert to static HTML.
Featured Image: This was created with PhotoFunia’s Developing Photos effect, with the source image being mine: