Hi there, my name is Alan Levine, you may have come across someone else online using my photos pretending to be someone else (I am not very active on Facebook, but have a profile there).
If I have shared this page with you, there is a good chance that you’ve been the target of a romance scam (aka
catfishing). You may have been led to believe that you are in a relationship with someone who looks like me. I am afraid to let you know that you have been fooled. The photos are me; the person? A fake.
Many of the photos these scammers use come from my own online photos — see
my Facebook album (no longer available) and a flickr set of photos (plus a larger number of tagged flickr images) known to have been used in fake profiles
However, you should know that scammers have been using my personal photos for several years to deceive women in the hopes of defrauding them of money or assets, or “romance scams”.
What is a Romance Scam?
A helpful definition of romance scams is:
“A romance scam is a confidence trick involving feigned romantic intentions towards a victim, gaining their affection, and then using that goodwill to commit fraud. Fraudulent acts may involve access to the victims’ money, bank accounts, credit cards, passports, e-mail accounts, or national identification numbers or by getting the victims to commit financial fraud on their behalf.” (Wikipedia)
I have been doing my best to bring this to the attention of the media and to social networks such as Facebook, Google, Skype, etc. However, there has been little to no response from these companies, and it is my strong belief that these corporations, in their lack of action against this growing problem, have now become complicit in these illegal activities.
If you are interested in learning more about my experience with these romance scammers, please read my blog posts about this topic, an article I published on medium, or a presentation I have done for university students.
Ranting Writing About Catfishing
I’ve written quite a bit here at CogDogBlog about my experiences (a few of these have strong language).
- You Can’t Catch the Catfishers… But You Can Play Out the Line And Waste Their Time (4/20/2016)
- Not Holding My Breath Waiting For Facebook’s New Account Impersonation Detection (3/23/2016)
- On Fakebook: Down, Not Out, Not Rolled Over (3/7/2016)
- We Regret To Inform of the Passing of Malle Gottfried’s Fakebook Profile (3/5/2016)
- The Logic of Facebook Fake Account Reviews: It Just Does Not Add Up (3/3/2016)
- Dear Facebook (2/28/2016)
- That Crazy Guy on the Corner Yelling #HEYFACEBOOK Looks Familiar (2/26/2016)
- Inside the (Weird) World of Facebook Catfishing (Part Deux With More Shame) (2/24/2016)
- Meet Halle Gottfried… (2/22/2016)
- #HEYFACEBOOK Why Won’t You Talk About Catfishing? (2/21/2016)
- A Catfishing Page (2/19/2016)
- The Latest Poop on CatfishBook and CatfishedIn (1/25/2016)
- Facebook is One Dumb Machine (11/26/2015)
- The Serenity Post (11/12/2015)
- I Do Not Know Who I Am Anymore. Neither Does Facebook, LinkedIn. (11/11/2015)
- Trying Medium.com to Call Out Facebook’s Coddling of Catfishers (11/7/2015)
- Catfishing is [NOT] Love and Timothy Boostrom is [NOT] Real (11/4/2015)
- Facebook as Catfish Paradise: Its Community Standards Wears the Cone of Shame (10/11/2015)
- No, You Can’t Use My Photo for Your Fake Identity, and No, I Can’t Prevent It (10/4/2014)
In a mostly failed attempt to be hip and reach the cool audience, I have
ranted written as well on medium.com:
What Can You Do?
What I can offer is sadly not much. And this is especially true if you have just discovered that you have been scammed, which means you are either in a place of shock and or shame.
- My identity has not been stolen or comprised. An an educator I have an easy to find presence online. Most victims find their way to me after doing a reverse image search.
- The people doing this are most likely overseas in a place beyond the reach of the law. They are highly organized and use sophisticated tools to cover their lies. There will always be excuses why their phone numbers do not work, or why they elude giving specific information. They can even use software that allows them to “call” you on Skype, but they will be projecting video of me. See this video for an example of how they do this
- If you live in the United States, file a report with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center – this does not mean the FBI will investigate but if they get reports from multiple victims it might raise their awareness.
- Report the fake accounts to the service where they have established fake profiles. Admittedly this does almost nothing, these scams use software that allows them to create multiple fake accounts easily. In my experience Facebook is very inconsistent in their “reviews” of accounts, sometimes taking them down quickly, other times it takes weeks or never. I have found that the more effective options are to report an account as fake, and the next option of “they are impersonating someone” — this works better if that person is a Facebook friend. It also seems to help if you can ask other people to report the accounts.
- Recognize that they used well-honed psychological tricks to prey on your vulnerabilities. After some period of often long online courtship, at some point they will ask for money. It might be to help them out of a financial bind (where they are cast as a victim, e.g. an ex), it might be to help them set up a business, it might be to supposedly buy a plane ticket to visit you. DO NOT SEND THEM MONEY!
- Once you discover their deceit, ignore all of their efforts to contact you. Block their numbers, delete any social connections, and do not respond to any of their efforts to reach you with some concocted story.
I am sorry this has happened to you. You are not stupid, you have been tricked by a professional scam artist. What you can do is report their profile as fake, and what would really help is to tell other people what has happened. It does not make you a fool or stupid, it makes you a victim, and there are a lot of victims.
If You Really Want Revenge– Waste Their Time! Let Them Think They are Still Fooling You…
While I doubt many victims would want to do this, if you really want to get back at them– you might consider how you can waste their time and effort. What I mean is continue to, like the fish, play them out, continue to act like you are in love, and do whatever you can to make them expend effort to fool you. For an inspiration in a different area of fraud, see what James Vietch did to email scammers:
And that was so much fun, right, that it got me thinking: like, what would happen if I just spent as much time as could replying to as many scam emails as I could? And that’s what I’ve been doing for three years on your behalf.
Crazy stuff happens when you start replying to scam emails. It’s really difficult, and I highly recommend we do it. I don’t think what I’m doing is mean. There are a lot of people who do mean things to scammers. All I’m doing is wasting their time. And I think any time they’re spending with me is time they’re not spending scamming vulnerable adults out of their savings, right?
If you are interested in baiting scammers, well how about that, there is a web site and community of people already doing it. Check out 419 Eater
Learn More About Romance Scams and Catfishing
And finally, here are some useful resources for learning more about romance scams including support groups that are dedicated to raising awareness, reporting fake profiles, and ultimately stopping these scammers.
- ‘Are You Real?’ – Inside An Online Dating Scam (AARP)
- RomanceScam.com (probably the best reporting and support group)
- Romance Scams (Facebook group)
- Scam Survivors
- Dating & romance (Scamwatch)
- Faking it – Scammers’ tricks to steal your heart and money (FTC)
- Tineye (search engine dedicated to reverse-image search)
- 419: The Internet Romance Scam (Documentary)
- Cybercrime Update: CatPhishing (Webpreserver)
- The Life of an Internet Catfish Is Rough These Days (Wired)
- How online scammers created a fake identity using little more than my picture (GeekWire)
- Online Dating Made This Woman a Pawn in a Global Crime Plot (Wired)
- FBI This Week Podcast: Romance Scames
- “Are you being catfished?” a constructive guide co-written/published by Alec Corous and by Katie Hildebrandt
This video is a tad over the top and has NSFW / child in-appropriate language, but does offer a simple test you can ask someone you are chatting with online… ask them to send you a photo touching their ear with their pinky finger, a rather unlikley pose they will find online.
This page is modeled after the one by Alec Couros, another educator who has been dealing with this situation even longer than me.
The page "I Am Alan Levine, These Are My Photos" was originally pulled from under moldy cheese at the back of the fridge at CogDogBlog (http://cogdogblog.com/i-am-alan/) on February 19, 2016.